Considering Consumer and Provider Rights in Privatizing Education

At the recent GCES symposium in RAK, researchers, policymakers, operators, and consulting companies were present to discuss the private-public education debate – UAE style. This was an invitation to reach a better understanding of the private-public education debate that is raging in Western countries and developing in practice in the Gulf.

The landscape, rules, policies, and governance is simply very different in the UAE because it caters to a different population of nationals and non-national children whose needs are diverse in terms of their long-term ambitions/realities.  The models of privatization that are being discussed in the West simply can’t be applied directly in the UAE. The models in the UAE are not being appreciated as learning opportunities by the West.

The timing for this particular symposium could not be more relevant. In the country today, quality control for consumer protection of this critical service (education) is being balanced with commercial rights of operators given the strong and growing business sector of private education. Pick up any of the local papers, and there is something about fee hikes, inspections, parental rights, access issues, and the list continues.

So what is happening now?

In Dubai, the KHDA is in their 3rd year of inspections. The caps on fee hikes has caused some ruffling of feathers for operators who are not pleased with any kind of cap on profit margins. On the other side of the fence, there are parents who are using the inspection results to make informed school choices within the constraints of availability and affordability of schools.

Interestingly, Abu Dhabi decided to do things a little less publicly. ADEC is stressing the need for a 3-year accreditation license that will be granted to private schools who achieve a grade that is – at least – good in overall performance and satisfactory given their standards. As of May 2011, ADEC will run a pilot application of the accreditation system in a number of Abu Dhabi schools with the full intention of scaling up for the entire of Abu Dhabi.

Unlike Dubai, the results of the Abu Dhabi inspections of private schools won’t be made public. Interesting.

The different models in these two emirates are worthy of serious attention from educational researchers. We are now living in a time where privatization of education is at the forefront of how we think about public education in the West, but there is insufficient attention given to alternate models. The UAE landscape calls for a real examination of policy, practice, and effect from educational researchers and evaluation experts to better understand the different options that exist along the public-private education continuum.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Considering Consumer and Provider Rights in Privatizing Education

  1. I am grateful for your alert to the lessons in privatization models in the UAE. Are some of these public-private partnerships? These are the models in NYC with which I am currently working (not only charters!) .

  2. Hi Elizabeth,

    PPPs in Abu Dhabi are very common. They started in 2006. The private operators are all international companies (e.g, Taaleem – EdisonLearning, Nord Anglia, and School Improvement Partnership (SIP) – GEMS). They started with 30 primary schools and as of 2009, they had 176 public schools up to secondary. It is all on the ADEC website.
    None in Dubai.

    GEMS recently signed with Kenya to open a school in Nairobi – check my LinkedIn for the press coverage on it. I believe that it is a PPP or version of it. 🙂

    I know that there is a real interest in expanding to the US market. Your research is timely. Look forward to reading on it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s